Quick answer
Button mushrooms grow in composted, manure-based substrate, usually horse manure mixed with straw or hay, poultry manure and gypsum, then pasteurized. Unlike oysters, they can’t break down raw straw or wood, so they need food that other microbes have already partly digested. After the compost is colonized, growers add a thin casing layer of limed peat on top, which is what triggers the mushrooms to fruit. Cremini and portobello grow the same way, because they’re the same species.
White button mushrooms are the most familiar mushroom in the grocery store, and also one of the pickiest about what they grow in. If you’ve tried them on straw or sawdust and gotten nothing, the substrate is almost certainly why. Here’s what button mushrooms actually need, and the easiest way to get it at home.
Button, cremini and portobello: one mushroom
| Name | What it is |
|---|---|
| White button | White strain of Agaricus bisporus, picked young |
| Cremini | Brown strain, picked young |
| Portobello | Brown strain, left to open fully |
Why button mushrooms need manure
Oysters and shiitake are wood decomposers. They can digest tough plant fiber on their own. Agaricus bisporus can’t. In nature it grows in rich, already-decomposing material like old pastures and compost heaps. Commercial growers recreate that by composting manure and straw until microbes have broken it down into food the mushroom can use. Penn State’s mushroom program lists horse manure, poultry manure, brewer’s grains, hay, corn cobs and gypsum among the standard ingredients.
How commercial compost is made
- Phase I: compostingIngredients are wetted, piled and turned. Penn State says Phase I is done when the material is dark brown, pliable, holds water and smells sharply of ammonia.
- Phase II: pasteurizing and conditioningCompost is held at about 115–140°F so helpful microbes thrive and pests die. Ammonia must drop below about 0.1 ppm, because ammonia kills mushroom spawn.
- SpawningThe cooled compost is mixed with grain spawn and left to colonize.
- CasingA layer of peat moss, limed from its natural pH of about 3.5–4.5 to around 7.5, goes on top. Penn State notes casing is what triggers fruiting.

Can you make it at home?
You can, but it’s the hardest part of growing button mushrooms. Composting takes weeks, space and a strong stomach, and if the ammonia doesn’t fully clear, the spawn won’t take. That’s why most home growers buy substrate ready to use. A pre-pasteurized manure-based bulk substrate, like Second Flush’s 3 lb bag pasteurized at 160°F and packed at field capacity, skips straight to the fun part: mix in colonized grain, wait, case and fruit.
| DIY compost | Pre-pasteurized bag | |
|---|---|---|
| Time to ready | Weeks | Open and use |
| Equipment | Outdoor pile, thermometer, pasteurizing setup | Clean hands and a tub or bag |
| Smell | Strong while composting | Mild and earthy |
| Risk | Ammonia or contamination if a step is off | Lower; prep is done |
Growing conditions at a glance
| Stage | Conditions |
|---|---|
| Colonizing compost | Warm, sealed, about 2–3 weeks |
| After casing | Keep casing moist for about a week while mycelium grows into it |
| Fruiting | About 60–66°F with fresh air (Penn State) |
| Harvest | Starts about 15–21 days after casing; flushes every 7–10 days |
FAQ
What do button mushrooms grow in?
Composted, pasteurized manure-based substrate, typically horse manure with straw or hay, poultry manure and gypsum, topped with a peat casing layer.
Can button mushrooms grow on straw or sawdust?
Not well. Unlike oysters, they can’t break down raw straw or wood and need composted substrate.
Does mushroom compost smell?
Finished, pasteurized compost smells mild and earthy. A strong ammonia smell means it isn’t finished.
Why do button mushrooms need a casing layer?
Penn State notes the casing layer is what triggers Agaricus to fruit. Without it, you’ll get few or no mushrooms.
Are cremini and portobello grown the same way?
Yes. They’re the same species as white button mushrooms, just a brown strain, with portobellos left to open fully.



